A Pyrrhic victory in Yerevan?

Only six weeks after parliamentary elections that saw the ruling Republican Party of Armenia retain its power, a municipal election in the Armenian capital Yerevan resulted in an even larger victory for the incumbent party. But as Richard Giragosian writes in his article A Pyrrhic victory in Yerevan? Understanding Armenia’s one party dominance for The London School of Economics and Political Science, the election result did little to obscure serious shortcomings in the voting process, with allegations of vote buying and interference by the ruling Republicans. And more troubling, the victory itself may have damaged the image and standing of the Republican Party, amid renewed concerns over the apparent risk of one-party rule in Armenia.

For many Armenian voters, after a heated parliamentary election in early April, the 14 May municipal election in the capital Yerevan was a bit of a letdown. The largely anti-climatic nature of the municipal election was also evident in the low turnout, as a mere 41 percent of eligible voters bothered to turn out to vote. Beyond a degree of political fatigue, many voters were also put off by the rather one-sided context, as the incumbent Republican Party was assured of a strong showing. That assurance was rooted in more than just confidence, however, but rather, stemmed from three inter-related factors.

First, unlike the more dramatic competition of the previous month’s parliamentary election, this time the ruling Republicans faced only one challenger: the recently crowned new opposition “Yelk” (Exit) bloc, a three-party coalition that emerged as the government’s most effective opponent in the new parliament. A third challenger, the outspoken but outgoing member of parliament Zaruhi Postanjyan, was never seen as more than a firebrand by voters. And the results only seemed to confirm the absence of real competition, with the ruling Republicans garnering some 71.3 percent, followed by 21 percent for the Yelk coalition, and less than 8 percent for Postanjyan.

But this lack of competition fostered a second reason for such voter disinterest. Yerevan voters were disappointed, if not disgusted, by the arrogance of the ruling authorities in the capital, which spurned offers to hold public debates and limited any serious discourse over pressing issues facing the capital. This refusal to address real concerns, ranging from traffic and transport problems to garbage collection, sparked public anger rather than apathy. Such arrogance was also matched by an egregious abuse of power, as the advantages of incumbency were flagrantly flouted and exceeded as voters in Yerevan were covertly pressured and coerced, while many more were openly bribed, often in “plain sight” and in spite of the presence of witnesses and media coverage.

And it was this pre-election arrogance of power, reflected in the over-confidence of the incumbent candidates, that reveals a third reason for the low turnout. This third factor is mounting concern over a now evident tendency toward one-party dominance, which first emerged in last month’s parliamentary election. Against a backdrop of dwindling patience for the government’s hurried move to transform the country into a parliamentary form of governance, any perception of political apathy seriously underestimates the mounting level of voter distrust and citizen mistrust.

From a broader perspective of back-to-back elections, it is now evident that the Armenian electorate has changed, and is no longer as tolerant, let alone apathetic, as it once was, especially as economic pressures increase. At the same time, and perhaps most significantly, the fact that the Armenian political landscape has also changed, irrevocably, suggests that despite the seeming “victory” of the ruling authorities, the loss of public trust and lack of legitimacy they are now experiencing may only hasten their political downfall.

About the author: Richard Giragosian is the Founding Director of the Regional Studies Center (RSC), an independent “think tank” in Yerevan, Armenia and serves as both a Visiting Professor at the College of Europe’s Natolin Campus and a Senior Expert at Yerevan State University’s Centre for European Studies (CES). He is also a contributing analyst for Oxford Analytica, a UK-based global analysis and advisory firm, and is a regular contributor to al Jazeera. For nine years, Giragosian served as a Professional Staff Member of the Joint Economic Committee (JEC) of the U.S. Congress.

1800 views


More Armenia News

Ilham Aliyev: international sanctions should have been imposed on Armenia long ago

Ilham Aliyev: international sanctions should have been imposed on Armenia long ago

The Nagorno-Karabakh conflict should be resolved within its territorial integrity on the basis of the norms and principles of international law and there's no other way, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev said, …

OSCE monitoring in Goranboy district passes without incidents

OSCE monitoring in Goranboy district passes without incidents

The monitoring of the Nagorno-Karabakh contact line in Azerbaijan's Goranboy district passed without any incident, Azerbaijan’s Defense Ministry said. The monitoring was held under the mandate of the OSCE …

Aznavour, Snoop Dogg and Minnie Mouse to receive stars on Hollywood Walk of Fame

Aznavour, Snoop Dogg and Minnie Mouse to receive stars on Hollywood Walk of Fame

Legendary French singer Charles Aznavour is among several entertainment professionals who have been selected to receive stars on the Hollywood Walk of Fame, the Walk of Fame Selection Committee of the Hollywood Chamber of …

EU: Nagorno-Karabakh status quo is unsustainable

EU: Nagorno-Karabakh status quo is unsustainable

The European Union commented the recent violations of the ceasefire, which have resulted in multiple casualties on the Line of Contact in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict zone. The statement says that recent violations of the ceasefire are …

Karabakh conflict’s settlement on Russian foreign ministry’s agenda

Karabakh conflict’s settlement on Russian foreign ministry’s agenda

The topic of settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict is always on the agenda of the Russian Foreign Ministry’s efforts, the spokesperson of the ministry Maria Zakharova said at a briefing. She also said that …

Azerbaijani Defense Ministry: Armenia uses combat drones once again

Azerbaijani Defense Ministry: Armenia uses combat drones once again

Armenian armed forces once again used unmanned combat aerial vehicles (UCAVs) on the line of contact between Armenian and Azerbaijani troops, the Azerbaijani Ministry of Defense said. The ministry added that due to their poor quality, …

Armenian UAV destroyed by Azerbaijani army

Armenian UAV destroyed by Azerbaijani army

The Azerbaijani Armed Forces destroyed an unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) belonging to Armenia’s Armed Forces on June 21 evening, Azerbaijan’s Defense Ministry said. The ministry noted that UAV attempted to carry out …

Direct flight between Armenia and Syria re-launched

Direct flight between Armenia and Syria re-launched

The direct air flight between Syria and Armenia will be re-launched after a long break. A trial Yerevan-Damascus flight of the Ajnihat Ash-Cham took place on Wednesday, the press-service of the Armenian Embassy said. The …

US State Department calls on sides to Nagorno-Karabakh conflict to avoid escalation

US State Department calls on sides to Nagorno-Karabakh conflict to avoid escalation

Washington is deeply concerned over the recent violations of the ceasefire, which have resulted in multiple casualties on the line of contact in Nagorno-Karabakh over the last week, US Sate Department Spokesperson Heather Nauert …

Footage of captured Armenian sabotage group member released (VIDEO)

Footage of captured Armenian sabotage group member released (VIDEO)

Видео

Azerbaijan’s Ministry of Defense has released footage of the captured member of an Armenian reconnaissance and sabotage group, Zaver Hovanis Karapetyan, who was born in the Noyemberyan district in 1974. A …

more Armenia News