Challenges Ahead For China’s Belt And Road Project

China’s bid to expand its economic presence in Eurasia – embodied in its “Belt and Road” initiative – requires a major upgrade of railway capacity, especially in Central Asia. Planning and implementing the upgrade entails significant challenges involving coordination, both domestically among various Chinese state agencies and entities, and internationally between China and Central Asian states. Eurasia Review reports in its article Central Asia: Challenges Ahead For China’s Belt And Road Project, theat the concept relies on three trunk lines running through Central Asia.

West Passage 1 exits from Xinjiang’s Alashankou (Khorgos), runs to Kazakhstan and moves on to a junction with Russia’s Trans-Siberian Railway. From there, the route can extend to the European Union via Belarus.

West Passage 2 exits Xinjiang’s Alashankou (Khorgos) and, via Kazakhstan, connects to Turkmenistan, Iran, Turkey and other countries, again with possible access to Europe; a branch also connects to the Caucasus via Kazakhstan and ferries across the Caspian Sea.

West Passage 3 connects China’s western city of Kashgar to Osh, in the Kyrgyz sector of the Ferghana Valley, via the Irkeshtam Pass. From there, the railway heads to Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, Iran, Turkey, and beyond.

Another trunk line, not involving Central Asian states, is called East Passage 1. It connects the Inner Mongolian town of Erenhot to the Trans-Siberian railway, and from there to Europe. So far, China’s efforts to address the coordination challenges have been hampered by a lack of a nuanced approach that accounts for the social and cultural sensitivities of its Central Asian neighbors.

In their dealings with Central Asian leaders, Chinese authorities have framed the Belt and Road in purely pragmatic, economic terms, calling it a “South-South” development policy that will produce a “win-win” economic situation for all involved. Many independent observers believe this appeal to pragmatism misses the point. Politically, Central Asian states are not all “mini-Chinas” with centralized political systems. The political complexion of Central Asia involves a wide array of governance structures, varying core-periphery power relations with Moscow, and, in some states, complex relations between central and regional authorities.

Meanwhile in the socio-economic sphere, officials in Beijing do not seem to appreciate concerns among Central Asian leaders, who believe China’s massive economy is capable of overwhelming their own economies, and have a transformational effect on their societies.

Internally, three corridors are being developed within China to funnel trade outward via rail. The West corridor comprises the northwest, southwest, central and southern regions, utilizing the Lanzhou-Urumqi railway network. The North corridor comprises the north, central and southern regions of China and utilizes to south-north Beijing-Guangzhou rail network. The East corridor comprises the northeast, east, central and other regions, utilizing the Beijing-Shanghai and Harbin-Dalian railway clusters.

A major component of China’s approach to address logistical dilemmas is a policy dubbed “international production capacity cooperation.” The idea is to reduce domestic overcapacity and disperse Chinese production, and, in the process, reduce railway choke points that could hamper the efficient distribution of exports produced by Chinese firms. Under the policy, Chinese firms are being encouraged to “go global” and move plants abroad. State-backed financial institutions are on notice to help whole domestic industry chains move offshore and to provide infrastructure investment in host countries that facilitates both the transit of exports, and the development of industrial capacity in those host countries.

Primary state responsibility for promoting the offshoring initiative will fall on provincial-level officials, backed by central planners. Chinese financial institutions are also creating financing mechanisms that will be available to provincial governments, which have their own Belt and Road policies that are supposed to be tailored to play to geographic, industrial-infrastructure and competitive-advantage strengths.

This strategy carries with it a couple of big risks. The biggest is perhaps a lack of institutional experience at the lower levels of China’s governing structure in dealing with counterparts abroad – something that could easily create a drag on the offshoring effort. If it is not handled deftly, China could end up exporting its problem of industrial overcapacity. For China to keep the Belt and Road railway component on track, it needs provincial officials to be up to the task of negotiating intricate international deals, and it also needs the domestic financial system to hold steady. Chinese officials additionally should tweak their approach toward Central Asian states, acknowledging the diversity of the region and engaging neighbors in a way that is more culturally tactful.

2335 views


More World news

Russian military to prevent Daesh’s retreat from Raqqa to Palmyra

Russian military to prevent Daesh’s retreat from Raqqa to Palmyra

Commanders of the Russian group of forces in Syria has taken measures to avert the withdrawal of the Islamic State militants from Raqqa towards Palmyra, which is located to the south, a source at the Russian Defense Ministry said, TASS …

Georgia to host 15th sport ministerial of Council of Europe

Georgia to host 15th sport ministerial of Council of Europe

15th ministerial of the Enlarged Partial Agreement on Sport (EPAS) will be held in Tbilisi in 2018, Georgian Prime Minister Giorgi Kvirikashvili informed. "It's very good for Georgia, it will improve …

Lithuanian charter airline to launch direct flights between Batumi and Warsaw

Lithuanian charter airline to launch direct flights between Batumi and Warsaw

Lithuanian charter airline Small Planet Airlines launches direct flights from Warsaw to Batumi. Airbus A320 will fly vie Warsaw - Batumi - Warsaw route every Sunday. …

Will the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor be a gateway to Central Asia?

Will the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor be a gateway to Central Asia?

The exchange of goods and energy is highly dependent on the normalization process in Afghanistan

Putin discusses Syria with Russian Security Council

Putin discusses Syria with Russian Security Council

Russian President Vladimir Putin has held a meeting with the permanent members of the national Security Council, Kremlin Spokesman Dmitry Peskov said. "As for global issues, the operation of the …

Kremlin dispels hopes of Putin-Trump meeting in Europe

Kremlin dispels hopes of Putin-Trump meeting in Europe

A meeting between Russian and US Presidents Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump is not expected to be held in the coming days in Europe, Kremlin Spokesman Dmitry Peskov said. "No …

Russia-NATO: is rapprochement possible?

Russia-NATO: is rapprochement possible?

There's still potential risk of an accidental conflict

Recommendations of an alternative to Trump’s hostility towards

Recommendations of an alternative to Trump’s hostility towards

There is an opportunity for improved relations with Iran

Italy’s Taormina hosts G7 summit

Italy’s Taormina hosts G7 summit

The 43rd summit of the G7, the group of most industrialized economies, opened in Taormina, a town in Italy’s Sicily, today. Friday’s plenary sessions will be devoted to foreign policy and security issues. In the wake of the …

 Why OPEC#039s production cut deal has been extended for another nine months

Why OPEC's production cut deal has been extended for another nine months

OPEC and countries outside the cartel, including Russia, have extended the deal on limiting oil output for another nine months

more World news