Japan proceeds cautiously with Russia

Shinzo Abe is conducting a curious diplomatic dance with Vladimir Putin. His timing may appear hard to understand, as events in Ukraine and Syria increase the distance between the Russian government and Japan’s allies in the EU and the US. The Japanese prime minister is, however, responding to a compelling long-term global logic. The challenge is to balance the strategic reasoning against acute short-term risks.

A trip to Japan for Mr Putin is planned for next month, his first visit as president in 11 years. Both leaders have invested in achieving a significant result. Mr Abe has publicly committed to breaking the deadlock in a territorial dispute over four islands, known in Russia as the Kuriles and in Japan as the Northern Territories. They were annexed by Russia at the end of the second world war. The dispute has prevented Tokyo and Moscow from signing a peace treaty to put an official end to that conflict.

The islands are an important, if symbolic, prize for Mr Abe. In 1972, Prime Minister Kakuei Tanaka normalised Japan’s relations with China, a coup regarded as one of the most significant postwar diplomatic achievements. Mr Abe hopes that greater influence with Russia will deter the forging of a deeper Chinese-Russian alliance.

Drawing closer to Russia is also part of Japan’s China strategy. In the East China Sea, conflict over the Senkaku Islands (known as the Diaoyu Islands in China), and China’s efforts to develop offshore gasfields, have heightened tensions between Japan and China. Mr Abe hopes to create space between China and Russia by drawing Russia closer.

To lay the groundwork, Japan is poised to expand its economic ties to Russia. Mr Abe sent his Hiroshige Seko, trade minister, to Moscow last week to discuss economic co-operation. Mr Putin likes this approach and he desperately needs foreign investment to push forward long-delayed energy development projects, particularly in Siberia. He has signalled willingness to negotiate over the disputed islands, sparking hope in Japan.

The world community is focused on maintaining a stable balance of power in the face of growing Chinese assertiveness. Japan’s approach could be useful in that regard: it decreases the chances that Russia is pushed permanently into China’s orbit, becoming the “junior partner” in an authoritarian bloc. Avoiding this outcome, however, will take decades.

In the medium term, Japan’s approach to Mr Putin threatens to weaken G7 co-ordination, and undermine sanctions against Moscow.

There are risks to Japan’s national interest, too. Many experts believe Japan can only hope to get two tiny islands back. Japan and the Soviet Union signed a joint declaration in 1956 stipulating the handover of Shikotan and Habomai, the two smallest islands, if and when a peace treaty is signed. The two make up 7 per cent of the islands’ land mass, and have little economic or security value. For this small gain, Japan cannot risk alienating the US or the EU.

Nor should Japan expect Russia to provide much meaningful support in its rivalry with China, even after a peace treaty is signed. Russia is deeply wary of China, but its hope for stronger economic ties, particularly in the form of pipelines to send natural gas eastward — is stronger still.

It is understandable that Japan wants to put a longstanding dispute behind it while seeking ways to counterbalance China’s growing regional strength. But doing so at the cost of splitting the G7 would be a serious mistake.

4205 views


More Russian news

Maria Zakharova to Vestnik Kavkaza: virtual fight against Russia replaces real fight against terrorism

Maria Zakharova to Vestnik Kavkaza: virtual fight against Russia replaces real fight against terrorism

Russia is using the whole range of measures to convince the West to jointly fight against terrorism, which is a common enemy for the whole world, but it don't receive an adequate response: many Western countries tend to present Moscow as …

NATO summit opens in Brussels

NATO summit opens in Brussels

Видео

The cumbersome bureaucratic and military structure of the bloc is useless in the fight against terrorism

 Putin: we should remember history lessons

Putin: we should remember history lessons

Russian President Vladimir Putin said that is is necessary to preserve a united Russian nation given the fragility of civil peace. According to the President, it is necessary to remember both happy and tragic pages …

 Moscow saved from transport terror attack

Moscow saved from transport terror attack

Russia’s federal security service FSB has detained four members of the outlawed terrorist organization ISIS in Moscow for plotting terrorist attacks at transport facilities. The FSB’s public relations center said that on May …

Russian Finance Minister on extension of oil deal: we should use favourable oil prices

Russian Finance Minister on extension of oil deal: we should use favourable oil prices

Russian Finance Minister Anton Siluanov said that he would support an extension of a global oil output cut deal as it should help Russia to replenish reserves. "The extension of the agreement is aimed at supporting …

Moscow allows supplies of Turkish vegetables to Russia

Moscow allows supplies of Turkish vegetables to Russia

Turkish products will be supplied to the Russian market immediately after the politically motivated trade restrictions are lifted, the head of Russia’s Federal Service for Veterinary and Phytosanitary Surveillance (Rosselkhoznadzor) …

Leningrad region and Republic of Azerbaijan preparing agreement

Leningrad region and Republic of Azerbaijan preparing agreement

They are going to significantly expand ties in the trade-economic, scientific-technical and cultural spheres

 Russian-Iranian oil deal finalized

Russian-Iranian oil deal finalized

The oil-for-food deal between  Russia and Iran is done, Iran’s petroleum minister Bijan Namdar Zanganeh said, adding that Iran expects supplies from Russia. "The deal is finalized and being carried out …

World Bank: Russia#039s inflation to decline bellow 4% in 2-3 years

World Bank: Russia's inflation to decline bellow 4% in 2-3 years

The World Bank predicts a decrease of inflation in Russia to less than 4% within 2-3 years. It will be possible due to the prudent policy of the Bank of Russia, the World Bank's Lead Economist for the Russian …

 Stoltenberg: high level dialogue between NATO-allied countries and Russia is very important

Stoltenberg: high level dialogue between NATO-allied countries and Russia is very important

NATO welcomes contact on a bilateral level between NATO-allied countries and Russia, NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg said ahead of the alliance summit due on May 25. "We have seen different meetings, …

more Russian news